A first clean sheet for Ruben Dias (£5.5m) in his Premier League career saw him pick up five FPL points in Man City's Gameweek 5 win over Arsenal, with a booking preventing the Portuguese star picking up any potential bonus points. Michael Keane (£5.1m) didn't pick up a clean sheet, however the Everton central defender found the net with a bullet header in their 2-2 draw with Liverpool, giving him a total of eight FPL points.
Next up for Dias is a trip to West Ham, whilst Keane's Everton travel down to Southampton. Two tough fixture in terms of clean sheet potential, with West Ham especially strong going forward having scored ten goals in their last three Premier League games. When taking this into account along with the fact that Keane is priced at £0.4m cheaper than Dias, then it is the Toffees man that wins favour with us.
Verdict: Michael Keane